Andy Cohen Shows Instagram Real Housewives Jen Shah’s Baby Gift: Did He Delete After Guilty Plea?

Andy Cohen finds a diplomatic way to get along with all the reality TV show stars he encounters as Bravo maestro. For instance, the “Watch What Happens Live” host even welcomes various Kardashian family members to his talk show. And when controversy strikes, Cohen stays calm. However, then “Real Housewives Of Salt Lake City” (RHOSLC) star Jen Shah entered the Bravo world. 

And Jen’s tale represents a caution for future Bravo reality TV stars. Pleading innocent to get Andy’s sympathy and then admitting guilty? Not a way to win over Andy Cohen! And his reaction demonstrates just how he feels. Find out how a gift for his baby daughter Lucy played into the Bravo maestro’s reaction. Get the details below!

Andy Cohen Overwhelmed With Baby Gifts From Stars!

“Real Housewives” stars know that Andy Cohen plays a key role in deciding whether they can continue on the network. As a result, reality TV stars overwhelmed him with gifts for his baby girl. And Andy often showcased them on his Instagram. However, that habit created a problem with Jen Shah, noted Heavy.

Jen had sent a present to Cohen’s second baby, a little girl named Lucy. And as he shared on Instagram, it included a sweet personal note on her customized paper. But the gift itself wowed fans and Andy even more.

Andy Cohen Shares Adorable Picture of His Baby Girl: 'Good Morning from Little Lucy!' https://t.co/ZYM2vwTFk3

— People (@people) May 31, 2022

Cohen expressed gratitude for “some great gifts for Lucy.” And he added, “Jen Shah [owns] unbelievable stationary with her own Shahmazing picture on it. [She]  sent, among other things, Lucy’s first hand-held mic.” And repeating that the gift appears “Shahmazing,” Andy summed up his delight. “I’m blown away. This is great,” he added.

Andy Cohen REACTS To Jen Shah’s Guilty Plea!

However, Cohen’s delight soon turned to dismay. Because when Shah switched her plea to guilty, Andy faced a dilemma. And he allegedly turned back to Instagram to delete his thanks to Jen. But Cohen also discussed his emotional response, per ET.

Andy Cohen reveals exactly how he feels about Jen Shah pleading guilty to fraud charges.https://t.co/EKvRdN5z9X

— Entertainment Tonight (@etnow) July 13, 2022

Cohen turned to his SiriusXM radio show to vent. And he called himself “upset” at Jen. But most of all, Andy feels “upset for her victims.” However, Cohen also took her lies personally.

For instance, the Bravo TV producer added, “She lied for so long and claimed [she exemplified] someone being wrongly accused.” And Andy recalled Shah at the RHOSLC reunion. As a result, he decided to believe her. But now Cohen feels betrayed.

“Because, frankly, you get to know someone and you get to like them,” he admitted.  As a result, Andy developed a “personal relationship” with Jen. “And you work with someone, you get to like them, you wanna cheer them on,” he added. But then he learned Shah indeed appeared “capable of this [illegal] behavior.” 

Tell us what you think. Do you sympathize with Andy Cohen for believing Jen Shah’s innocent plea? Or did you feel that she seemed guilty even before her confession? And after you share your views, check back on our site for more celebrity news!

Editorial credit: lev radin / Shutterstock.com